me_saket 73 Report post Posted July 13, 2009 Check for new plans of Tata Docomo Post Paid Where did u get this from? May be these are the plans they formed before launching current plans.. BTW the presentation shows how detail they have studied the tariff. Good work.. I don't think so. Those plans will be for POSTPAID customer, possibly for corporate connections. As this is having CUG facility and no rent for VAS. STILL plans are good, Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
vvinayakpai 26 Report post Posted July 13, 2009 ^^^^^^^ The cc representative you spoke to might have been poached from RCOM I find it really hard to believe though. The advertisements in todays times of india, bangalore edition, clearly mentions that Tata Docomo clearly reserves the right to modify the tariff.......etc. This gives me all the more reason to disbelieve the cc Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Himanshu Singh 19 Report post Posted July 13, 2009 HA HA. I posted earlier that tata cdma started with similar schemes and then it vanished. I am of the view that sooner or later do co mo will fall in line. Other operators are not going to copy it for per second billing. Virgin started with get paid for incoming but did any other operator, old or new, copy it? Its my personal view,others may fancy better things like say per character billing for texts- 1paise per 300 characters? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
srk006 21 Report post Posted July 13, 2009 Also, when tariffs are bound to fall to 30p/min for local(Which I believe will happen ), per-second billing will become costlier. The minimum tariff will cannot go below 1p/sec which translates to 60p/minute. So per-minute will be the best. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
savramesh 37 Report post Posted July 13, 2009 ^^^ it can go below 1p/1sec -> 1p/2sec [effective charge 0.5p/1sec] docomo has that 1p/2sec for onnet pack i guess... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ravi_patent 28 Report post Posted July 13, 2009 (edited) srk make the most of now (per sec billing is good now..and as Ramesh has shown earlier it offers good deal of financial advantage as of now ) and if needed let change be the way of life (MNP will take care of number).. Edited July 13, 2009 by ravi_patent Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
anshu_s09 18 Report post Posted July 13, 2009 call tarrif will surely fall by the end of this year to 25- 30 paise per minute faor local call, in this case per second billing will be costly, same thing was there when tata 1st launched its cdma service( billing on per second) but tata had to withdraw per second billing within 8 months of launch as it was costlier due to fall in tarrif.. so even we can see per second billing coming to an end very soon, as soon as the call tarrif will fall Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
me_saket 73 Report post Posted July 13, 2009 call tarrif will surely fall by the end of this year to 25- 30 paise per minute faor local call, in this case per second billing will be costly, same thing was there when tata 1st launched its cdma service( billing on per second) but tata had to withdraw per second billing within 8 months of launch as it was costlier due to fall in tarrif.. so even we can see per second billing coming to an end very soon, as soon as the call tarrif will fall But still i will prefer second billing, over minutes, coz my calls are not generally of long duration. or for long duration calls, i will purchase another sim(possibly prepaid), and use dual sim handset. Prepaid card help me to save to only those calls whch are long duration Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
vvinayakpai 26 Report post Posted July 14, 2009 Is cell info display functional on Tata Docomo network? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
shashank 8 Report post Posted July 14, 2009 (edited) ^^Yes it is. And its pretty Accurate Edited July 14, 2009 by shashank Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
bhargavachandra 3 Report post Posted July 14, 2009 Is cell info display functional on Tata Docomo network? Dear Mr. Vinayak Pai, Yes, the cell info display is functional in AP too. They are broadcasting the location name of the tower. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
savramesh 37 Report post Posted July 15, 2009 (edited) 15 days of usage Tariff comparison Tariff A = Local 1p/1sec and STD 1p/sec [Pulse 1 sec] Tariff B = Local 60p/1min and STD 60p/1min [Pulse 60 secs] Tariff C = Local 50p/1min and STD Re1/1min [Pulse 60 secs] Tariff D = Local Re1/1min and STD Rs 1.5/1min [Pulse 60 secs] Calls so far charged based on Tariff A = Rs 60.36 Same calls Charged if based on Tariff B = Rs 74.40 Same calls Charged if based on Tariff C = Rs 88.50 Same calls Charged if based on Tariff D = Rs 150.50 % saved Tariff A vs Tariff B = 18.87 % [Rs. 14.04] % saved Tariff A vs Tariff C = 31.80 % [Rs. 28.14] % saved Tariff A vs Tariff D = 59.89 % [Rs. 90.14] The more you call the more you save.. No connectivity problem, No dropped calls, No missed calls.. Good going.. Edited July 15, 2009 by savramesh Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
srk006 21 Report post Posted July 15, 2009 ^^ WOW. Nice workout. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
KumaarShah 143 Report post Posted July 15, 2009 @ramesh, which are the operators b, c and d? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
srk006 21 Report post Posted July 15, 2009 ^^ Seems to be just various scenarios of using STVs Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
me_saket 73 Report post Posted July 16, 2009 15 days of usageTariff comparison Tariff A = Local 1p/1sec and STD 1p/sec [Pulse 1 sec] Tariff B = Local 60p/1min and STD 60p/1min [Pulse 60 secs] Tariff C = Local 50p/1min and STD Re1/1min [Pulse 60 secs] Tariff D = Local Re1/1min and STD Rs 1.5/1min [Pulse 60 secs] Calls so far charged based on Tariff A = Rs 60.36 Same calls Charged if based on Tariff B = Rs 74.40 Same calls Charged if based on Tariff C = Rs 88.50 Same calls Charged if based on Tariff D = Rs 150.50 % saved Tariff A vs Tariff B = 18.87 % [Rs. 14.04] % saved Tariff A vs Tariff C = 31.80 % [Rs. 28.14] % saved Tariff A vs Tariff D = 59.89 % [Rs. 90.14] The more you call the more you save.. No connectivity problem, No dropped calls, No missed calls.. Good going.. also consider tariff d : local 1p/1se and std 2p/1sec. good work @ramesh, which are the operators b, c and d? b = docomo with minute pulse. c= rcom jadu pack d= any operato's lifetime sim card 's default tariff Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ravi_patent 28 Report post Posted July 16, 2009 airtel seems to be reacting docomo offer.. airtel is selling prepaid sims for 10 rs with 60p/min tariff in chennai Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
bhargavachandra 3 Report post Posted July 16, 2009 15 days of usageTariff comparison Tariff A = Local 1p/1sec and STD 1p/sec [Pulse 1 sec] Tariff B = Local 60p/1min and STD 60p/1min [Pulse 60 secs] Tariff C = Local 50p/1min and STD Re1/1min [Pulse 60 secs] Tariff D = Local Re1/1min and STD Rs 1.5/1min [Pulse 60 secs] Calls so far charged based on Tariff A = Rs 60.36 Same calls Charged if based on Tariff B = Rs 74.40 Same calls Charged if based on Tariff C = Rs 88.50 Same calls Charged if based on Tariff D = Rs 150.50 % saved Tariff A vs Tariff B = 18.87 % [Rs. 14.04] % saved Tariff A vs Tariff C = 31.80 % [Rs. 28.14] % saved Tariff A vs Tariff D = 59.89 % [Rs. 90.14] The more you call the more you save.. No connectivity problem, No dropped calls, No missed calls.. Good going.. Nice analysis, Mr. Ramesh!! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
savramesh 37 Report post Posted July 16, 2009 @ramesh, which are the operators b, c and d? B is just to know if it was min pulse instead of sec pulse C - not sure which operator, but have heard/seen here D is basic tariff of operators without any rate cutters or offers BTW the same calls with MTS 49p/sec tariff is Rs. 60.76 whereas my docomo charge is Rs. 60.36, this shows mts new tariff is almost effective as docomo.. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
vvinayakpai 26 Report post Posted July 16, 2009 Wonderful analysis Mr. Ramesh. Easy to understand and a very effective way of explaining the facts. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
me_saket 73 Report post Posted July 17, 2009 http://www.tatadocomo.com/dive-in.aspx dive in portal lik activated with many services like call me tune gprs etc. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
KanagaDeepan 1,084 Report post Posted July 17, 2009 (edited) airtel seems to be reacting docomo offer.. airtel is selling prepaid sims for 10 rs with 60p/min tariff in chennai In my humble opinion, 60p/min IS MUCH COSTLIER THAN 1p/sec... Because NOT ALL CALLS ends in 60 secs.. It should be atleast either 40p/min to compete with Docomo's 1p/sec... My BSNL postpaid Plan525 tariff is in 15 sec pulse and 40p/min for any local, that is 10p/15 sec... So far only this tarif will be better than Docomo's tariff.. It is best suited for both SHORT AS WELL AS LONG conversations.. For very long conversations there is CUG... But the catch here is Rental Rs525.. But as a heavy user like me the bundled Rs300 free usage(Local/STD), 55 MB FREE GPRS, 300 min ROAMING INCOMING FREE, 15p/15sec STD, CUG, 20p/min to 2 LandLines, VAST COVERAGE even in rural areas, prevents from choosing from DoCoMo... But for all other users (almost 99% o total users), DoCoMos current tarif is BEST suited... Edited July 18, 2009 by kanagadeepan Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
MOBILE FAN 42 Report post Posted July 17, 2009 (edited) Its a cool plan - BSNL 525. I just jumped over it. But then I calculated for my usage. Apart from 250-300 minutes local usage I have 1000-1200 minutes of STD usage. With this plan I would cross 1200/1300 Rs/Month. I think, I am still better with Reliance 440 Unlimited plan where my bill never crossed Rs. 750. Btw, when docomo will start operations in Maharashtra ? Edited July 17, 2009 by MOBILE FAN Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
siva1983in 1 Report post Posted July 18, 2009 Poor start by Tata Docomo.. Its advertised everywhere and in their website that there is a STV of Rs.25 (Tamilnadu Circle) which gives a local onnet tariff of 1p/2S. It is not available anywhere in paper form. If I e-topup for Rs.25, I get equivalent talk time only. Poor start from DOCOMO Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
bhargavachandra 3 Report post Posted July 18, 2009 Poor start by Tata Docomo.. Its advertised everywhere and in their website that there is a STV of Rs.25 (Tamilnadu Circle) which gives a local onnet tariff of 1p/2S. It is not available anywhere in paper form. If I e-topup for Rs.25, I get equivalent talk time only. Poor start from DOCOMO Dear Mr. Shiva, I would like to inform you that the STV 25 (Juice Up) is available as stated on the website. Probably the retailer you approached might not be aware of this. In the retailer SIM card given to retailers there is a sub-menu called 'SPECIAL RECHARGE'. If they recharge through regular recharge sub-menu it will be considered a talktime value since Tata DoCoMo E-recharge for talk time is not fixed.....you can recharge anywhere between Rs. 10 to Rs.10,000. So what ever value he enters in the regular recharge sub-menu, whether it's 25 or 75 or 777, it will be considered as talktime by the server program. So the next time you visit that retailer, please tell him to recharge through SPECIAL RECHARGE sub-menu and insist that if he makes a mistake, you'll not pay him. If he says he doesn't know what a special recharge sub-menu is, then please tell him to "go to that sub-menu from where he does that Rs. 51 recharge", which every retailer does immediately after activation of a new number. I think you got this. Should you face any problem with regard to this, please feel free to post the same. The third-party retailer segment is woefully un-structured and they don't present with any professional behavior. We can't take the word from such third-party retailers and mistake the service provider for that. Best Regards 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites