amitnsonu 72 Report post Posted June 8, 2011 guys I think this topic should also be on forum so that we know if the purpose of MNP is fulfiled by our new network or not.. Hope every body will get benefitted my Post MNP experience experience is here MNP done : 1 April 2011 (No april fool) operators : RCDMA to Aircel (Delhi) Reason : better network with affordable plans first I was thinking of vodafone (really a king among all networks IMHO) but it was too costly in postpaid, then i decided to go with aircel with plan SIMPLE VALUE 499 details: Rent 499 free airtime local/std/ onnet roaming : 1000 minutes free sms local/std : 2500 sms data : upto 2 gb in home circle only (although i have noticed they have not charged me for roaming data) caller tunes free after free usage call rate : 1p/sec std/local/onnet roaming sms : 30 p local, 60p std i was not getting proper network with RCDMA in basement and facing call drops even at 5th floor, called and mailed RCOM several times regarding this but no solution. with aircel, i m getting proper network everywhere, no call drops till now. when my 2 billing cycles get completed on 27 may, then again I thought of bargaining with aircel too, sent port out sms..... no call back from aircel, but i m getting noticed from unbilled usage that they are giving me 25% discount from 27 may i.e. effective rental 374.25 Rs Per month :Sorprendido:... consumer is really king now... thats from my side, waiting for others opinion 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
drmuralimreddy 0 Report post Posted June 8, 2011 shifted to idea from airtel in jan on 30th voice clarity good but poor data services GPRS is slow recently travelled to himachal pradesh coverage on roaming is poor and no GPRS service on national roaming not that happy with IDEA Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ankurcshah 112 Report post Posted June 8, 2011 I don't think anyone would port from AIRTEL to IDEA. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
abhisathe 8 Report post Posted June 8, 2011 my porting experience: Time of porting: Around mid January 2011 Operators: From Idea to RCDMA Reason: Poor Idea network in my south Mumbai office. No improvement despite follow up for one year Experience: On network part, I face no problem at all now in my office. RCDMA network is appreciably good in Mumbai and around. I do not need to access email or internet on phone, so have the basic but really cute Mpower TV239 model. It works really well. On tariff part, earlier subscribed to the 50p RCDMA postpaid tariff. Had some hiccups as I added the 30p tariff but I was billed for 50p. After a mail, I was given a refund and things are fine on that front. Used Palm Pixi for few days and found RCDMA EVDO absolutely amazing. But...... MTS bundled handset offers are really tempting. I wish RCDMA also introduces something like that. Till then, I am happy with RCDMA. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gyanesh 0 Report post Posted August 9, 2015 Recently I did National-MNP by porting my "Idea"s Delhi/NCR connection to "Idea" UP-West circle's. After, N-MNP, I noticed that I am able to call that number ( i.e. ported one) from any Delhi/NCR mobile as a local number i.e. without prefixing "0" or "+91". Then I tried to call some other UP-West's number from my Delhi mobile number and all the calls got connected as local call. The same is happening when calling from UP-West number to Delhi/NCR number. Has anybody else noticed this ? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
sujit_k 141 Report post Posted August 9, 2015 Recently to comply with nmnp all operators have done away with the 0. You can call any mobile without prefixing 0 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
M.S.Rao 64 Report post Posted August 10, 2015 Recently I did National-MNP by porting my "Idea"s Delhi/NCR connection to "Idea" UP-West circle's. After, N-MNP, I noticed that I am able to call that number ( i.e. ported one) from any Delhi/NCR mobile as a local number i.e. without prefixing "0" or "+91". Then I tried to call some other UP-West's number from my Delhi mobile number and all the calls got connected as local call. The same is happening when calling from UP-West number to Delhi/NCR number. Has anybody else noticed this ? Sir, Have you verified the call charges including for incoming calls. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gyanesh 0 Report post Posted August 10, 2015 Recently I did National-MNP by porting my "Idea"s Delhi/NCR connection to "Idea" UP-West circle's. After, N-MNP, I noticed that I am able to call that number ( i.e. ported one) from any Delhi/NCR mobile as a local number i.e. without prefixing "0" or "+91". Then I tried to call some other UP-West's number from my Delhi mobile number and all the calls got connected as local call. The same is happening when calling from UP-West number to Delhi/NCR number. Has anybody else noticed this ? Sir, Have you verified the call charges including for incoming calls. I have post-pay connection so call charges can be verified only after bill generation. I think i could not explain my view. "By local call" I mean call gets connected without prefixing "0" or "+91" and it had nothing to do with call charges. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
dkaile 1,051 Report post Posted August 11, 2015 Really happy post MNP from Reliance CDMA postpaid to Airtel 3G/4G Postpaid. The network of Airtel is quite good in UP West, in fact better than Reliance CDMA in some places. Reliance GSM is comparison was just too pathetic. Data speeds on 3G are better than Reliance EVDO - Cheers... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ashishsethi 55 Report post Posted August 11, 2015 Really happy post MNP from Reliance CDMA postpaid to Airtel 3G/4G Postpaid. The network of Airtel is quite good in UP West, in fact better than Reliance CDMA in some places. Reliance GSM is comparison was just too pathetic. Data speeds on 3G are better than Reliance EVDO - Screenshot_2015-08-10-17-53-02.jpg Cheers... Can you elaborate about the plan you chose? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
dkaile 1,051 Report post Posted August 11, 2015 Really happy post MNP from Reliance CDMA postpaid to Airtel 3G/4G Postpaid. The network of Airtel is quite good in UP West, in fact better than Reliance CDMA in some places. Reliance GSM is comparison was just too pathetic. Data speeds on 3G are better than Reliance EVDO - Screenshot_2015-08-10-17-53-02.jpg Cheers... Can you elaborate about the plan you chose? I chose the 299 plan with 8 packs, all of 3G i.e. total 960MB 3G data + on porting I got 300 minutes local/std calls free per month. Alternatively with family members I can chose the My Family Plan and start at 399 with 12 packs i.e. approx 1.5GB data free and after that unlimited 2G data; No rental after 1st month (199) for all the additional 4 family members. 300 minutes calling free for each member porting into Airtel. Data is shared amongst all members and plan can be increased to 499 or 599 if more data is required. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ti_user 12 Report post Posted August 11, 2015 @dkaile Reason for port out? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
dkaile 1,051 Report post Posted August 12, 2015 @dkaile Reason for port out? 1. Lack of proper handsets and at proper prices. I was the first user of Reliance in West UP. When we started using CDMA, high quality handsets were easily available at half the price of their gsm counterparts, 2. Dying network. Will be finished soon after Jio. 3. Lack of transparency. 4. No 4G Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
amitnsonu 72 Report post Posted August 12, 2015 I ported out of relaince cdma network in 2011 because of network issue as well as non availability of affordable handsets. Now I am back on RCDMA because of failure of GSM network at my place. RCDMA is working here as a charm however evdo speed is not more than 600 kbps. Handset availabilty is far more better than 2011. Now I am using Droid Maxx with GSM/CDMA capability on single sim which we couldnt imagine in 2011. Data prices are as important as 3g/4g network, which in current scenario are simply very high. I have consumed 8 GB in my last billing cycle on RCDMA network, which may have cost me min. 1000/- on 3G. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
