Amir Khan Against Gujarat's Narmada Dam

[prakashkadam 1]

Narendra Modi is a b*****d...

He should meet the same fate as the corrupt politician in Rang De Basanti met. Youngesters shoot that b*****d and let India improve and modernize.

Such stupid politicians should be shot dead on the middle of the road who steal away common people's democracy and make them fool.

you have lost your sense, why blame modi here?

Gujarati's across the political arena, whether BJP or Congress have a grudge against Amir.

And regarding the rehabilitation of dam affected farmers Gujarat have done its lot, its the problem in MP only.

[Ramchi 0]

There are so many issue in India

In Kashmir so many dies every day.

Why he shut ???.

MARNEKA DAR LAGTA HE !!!

Aamir knew that by supporting Kashmir Hindus he will not get enough publicity as he does against Modi Government in Gujarath. It is all about money and Aamir is playing his dirty role in the name of freedom of expression. For me the whole episode of Medha Padkar was probably organized by Aamir & Co as publicity stunt for their upcoming movie which worked perfectly.

Aamir neither cares for displaced nor he bothers who gets killed in Kashmir. He zimply wants to make more money which is fine with me but trying cheap tactics is not good for him.

Let Gujarath people allow the movie to be screened and if they do not like Aamir let them not watch his movies. I do not want any political ban on anything unless it is determining security of this country. In this case there is apparently no political ban but for some reasons (most likely financial reasons) these multliplex owners are refusing to show it in Gujarath. For them Aamir and Narmada is a good excuse.

In my opinion, Aamir’s was mostly successful in his attempt to garner publicity but boomeranged in Gujarath.

Narendra Modi is a b*****d...

He should meet the same fate as the corrupt politician in Rang De Basanti met. Youngesters shoot that b*****d and let India improve and modernize.

Such stupid politicians should be shot dead on the middle of the road who steal away common people's democracy and make them fool.

I would say the same on every Congress politician in this country. Atleast BJP has one Modi but in Congress everyone is a Modi.

[adwait 0]

The theatre owners have not decided to not show the movie volountarily. Agreed there's no official ban on the movie, but the theatre owners know that if they screen the movie, their theatre will be ransacked by mobs.....and when I say mobs, I don't mean the "people of gujarat" but the goondas of BJP and other political goondas.

[Ramchi 0]

"their theatre will be ransacked by mobs....."

So this is basically an assumption. Is it not possible that owners wanted better share from the distributers?

What will you say on those mobs which killed some innocent bystanders during "Danish Cartoon" protest march?

Let us not have double standards here.

[MOBILE FAN 42]

Aamir knew that by supporting Kashmir Hindus he will not get enough publicity as he does against Modi Government in Gujarath. It is all about money and Aamir is playing his dirty role in the name of freedom of expression. For me the whole episode of Medha Padkar was probably organized by Aamir & Co as publicity stunt for their upcoming movie which worked perfectly.

Aamir neither cares for displaced nor he bothers who gets killed in Kashmir. He zimply wants to make more money which is fine with me but trying cheap tactics is not good for him.

Let Gujarath people allow the movie to be screened and if they do not like Aamir let them not watch his movies. I do not want any political ban on anything unless it is determining security of this country. In this case there is apparently no political ban but for some reasons (most likely financial reasons) these multliplex owners are refusing to show it in Gujarath. For them Aamir and Narmada is a good excuse.

In my opinion, Aamir’s was mostly successful in his attempt to garner publicity but boomeranged in Gujarath.

Let Aamir have the freedom to express himself. And you know, our case is becoming more complecated. We are punishing Aamir for the offence that he never commited. But we are tolerating you even though you spell Gujarat as "Gujarath" !

[Ramchi 0]

"But we are tolerating you even though you spell Gujarat as "Gujarath"

How about Danish cartoon protesters & Da Vinci Code protesters? Did you tolerate them as well?

Edited May 31, 2006 by Ramchi

[KingofKalyan 0]

World is running away day by day.....

And We Indians dont get time to be out of critizing each other....

[adwait 0]

"their theatre will be ransacked by mobs....."

So this is basically an assumption. Is it not possible that owners wanted better share from the distributers?

What will you say on those mobs which killed some innocent bystanders during "Danish Cartoon" protest march?

Let us not have double standards here.

I'll say the same thing, that they were political goondas. The common people don't have the time/inclination do pull such stunts. The only truly peoples movement today is the anti reservation stir.....baaki all political bakwaas.

[KingofKalyan 0]

I saw the film........

1st of Half is goood.

2nf half is kinda boring

And Something for Gujrat People "Rehan ( AAMIR) Appse Jitna Pyar Karta hain, App unse utna nahi karte"

Edited June 4, 2006 by KingofKalyan

[JRMODI 0]

Nobody understands real problem. Right of speech is there for everybody. Amir should have it also. But.. the people is angry because Amir is a celebrity. Speeach of a celebrity matters a lot. It has got lot of impact of mindset of lakhs of people.

Gujarat has invested 25000 crores in this project. NBA is responsible for the delay of the project. One day of delay costs our country in crores. Gujarat had to raised the money from market because of denial of loan from wolrdbank and other organization because of protest of NBA and other organisations. So when the court said that dam hight should be raised to 125 mts these people want to stop work by diverting the issue to some other topic.

This is my view on the whole issue & that is why I don't want to watch FANNA on theatre and on CD as well.

[KingofKalyan 0]

What is the connection between FANAA and DAM ????

What makes a sense in that ? To not watch his Movie Fanaa ???????

[Dhirens 1]

Dear Friends,

I wish to express my views on the issue.

I am neither in favour of Aamir nor in favour of BJP/N.Modi for this issue.

I like Aamir as an actor. However I feel that his speech and his stand is a political... He should have not given any comments on Narmada especially at Indiagate in front of Media.

Supreme Court was about to give its decision on Narmada Dam. Neither medha Patkar Nor BJP or nobody had requested Aamir to come to India Gate to express his personal views. From his act, I feel that he was interested in publicity for faana or was really childish to act so like guys shown in rang De Basanti.

I agree with him that he has right to express his views and its his fundamental rights. However the platform choosen by him was not correct. He could have express his views to his wife no.1 or wife no.2 or to his frends or Director of rang de basanti..... Even we have our own views for narmada but we dont go to India Gate to express it in front of Media.

He definitely went to India gate to get a cheaper publicity as he is an actor and media would love to cover him. This part hurts everyone. His stand was only for a day and he may not be anymore with Medha patkar and team. He may not join future protests and activities of medha Patkar. Is this a stand ?

Where was Aamir when Doctors were protesting reservations ???? Whats his stand on this issue ? 2 days back, on STAR PLUS he said in an interview that we all Indians must understand that political parties are in existance who wish to divide the nation in name of religion and jaati-vaad and etc. As per this philosophy, Congress and Left parties are dividing nation in the name of Jaati-Vaad and reservation issue. however Aamir doesn't want to give comments on reservation.

Aamir has no comments for terrorist attack on Akshardham in Gujarat but he pointed out some incidents where Muslims were sufferors in Gujarat riots.

In short, Aamir has no stand. He doesn't wish to accept that he was wrong and his views have hurt people of India. He could have avoid all problems by saying sorry to people who love them. But he prefered not to say sorry to people of India in the name of freedom of speech.

Even Narendra Modi / Govt of India / Gujarat Govt. is in favour of rehabilitation of land owners who would loose their land due to naramda dam. No Indians or Govt have ever stated that dam should be constructed at the cost of any loss to farmers. So in short, Aamir's view are much similar to Narendra Modi. However Narendra Modi doesn't bark like Aamir.

I really feel very bad because Faana is not released in Gujarat. Movie should have been allowed to release in Gujarat. however people of india should have made protest to the movie and prefered not to watch it. I would request all Indians not to see this movie because Aamir has made this stunt just for Faana.

We must not trouble movie makers or coca cola or toyota because Aamir is associated with him. We must not disturb them too. However it is in our hand to use their product or not. We must not watch movies of Aamir or use products for which he is campaigning.

We must tell Aamir Khan that we love actor Aamir Khan and not politician Aamir Khan. And for arrogant Aamir khan, we have no place in our heart. If Aamir is in favour of Narmada Dam, he must issue statement that he is in favour of Narmada dam and had no intention to hurt people of India. He must withdraw his one day stand to Medha and must say sorry to people of India.

And my friends, it was the message from rang De Basanti " ya to chup baitho ya kuch karo" So someone declared ban on this movie because of Aamir's chilish move...... now why Aamir is crying ? Why he is making stories everyday in paper and tv ? Say sorry and close the chapter...... Or enjoy the fruit of your deeds.

It is unfortunate that we are not united.... Aamir has given this message to all Indians that we must believe in Unity and stay away from people who wants to divide. We must accept this view and we must together protest this movie in entire India. Dont stop release of Aamir's movies or dont burn his posters..... simply stay away from his movies and product he promots.

If tomorrow some celebrity says that Kashmir must be given to pakistan, will you accpet such arguments in name of freedom of speech ?????? Ya to chup baitho ya kuch karo. Aamir must say sorry....

Sorry Aamir, but thats my views for politician Aamir. Its time to faana....

[adwait 0]

Where was Aamir when Doctors were protesting reservations ???? Whats his stand on this issue ? 2 days back, on STAR PLUS he said in an interview that we all Indians must understand that political parties are in existance who wish to divide the nation in name of religion and jaati-vaad and etc. As per this philosophy, Congress and Left parties are dividing nation in the name of Jaati-Vaad and reservation issue. however Aamir doesn't want to give comments on reservation.

Aamir has no comments for terrorist attack on Akshardham in Gujarat but he pointed out some incidents where Muslims were sufferors in Gujarat riots.

In short, Aamir has no stand. He doesn't wish to accept that he was wrong and his views have hurt people of

Huh?? So anybody who expresses his views about one controversy is obligated to express his views about every other controversy in the country??? That's just silly.

[Dhirens 1]

Huh?? So anybody who expresses his views about one controversy is obligated to express his views about every other controversy in the country??? That's just silly.

No. The point is "Dont express your views on controversy or have views on all controversy to justify yourself"

[tanveer 59]

Chodo yaar. all these people celebrities, politicians and bigwigs are fake.

Nobody cares about the public. Sab apne point banate hain.

[MOBILE FAN 42]

Nobody understands real problem. Right of speech is there for everybody. Amir should have it also. But.. the people is angry because Amir is a celebrity. Speeach of a celebrity matters a lot. It has got lot of impact of mindset of lakhs of people.

Mr. JRModi,

First of all we should understand the problem. When you say that Aamir has right of speech etc.. etc.. and then you show your problem, you should first understand what Aamir has said. Plz. dont go by the image of what the Gujarati media has created. Please read his speech in double-quotes. I agree with what you said that speech of celebrity matters a lot but in your case the thing is that the bad image created for celebrity matters a lot. Here is what he said - Transcript of his interview.

Gujarat has invested 25000 crores in this project. NBA is responsible for the delay of the project. One day of delay costs our country in crores. Gujarat had to raised the money from market because of denial of loan from wolrdbank and other organization because of protest of NBA and other organisations. So when the court said that dam hight should be raised to 125 mts these people want to stop work by diverting the issue to some other topic.

I fully agree with you that Gujarat has invested thousand of crores. Also agree with the NBA's role. But dont know whom you are referring when you say "these ppl want to stop work". I am sure you are not referring to Aamir.

This is my view on the whole issue & that is why I don't want to watch FANNA on theatre and on CD as well.

You have right to have the view but our bad luck is that you have view without knowing the proper things. you dont know what Aamir has said. If you dont want to watch Fana then it your chioce. But going by that logic, I have a request to you, please dont drink Coke, dont take lift in any Toyota and above all sell you LG handset immediately because the latest ad. of LG shows Aamir with Fana's clip.

Man... I have only one thing to say.... lets be mature, lets go in detail before airing our view. Lets not just go by image but the fact.

[MOBILE FAN 42]

Dear Friends,

I wish to express my views on the issue.

You are welcome.

I am neither in favour of Aamir nor in favour of BJP/N.Modi for this issue.

Thats a good stand. But looking at the other part of your view the statement doesnt seem true.

I like Aamir as an actor. However I feel that his speech and his stand is a political... He should have not given any comments on Narmada especially at Indiagate in front of Media.

Agree, everybody loves Aamir as an actor. You are right lots of people have "feel", lots of ppl have "image"... but these ppl dont know what Aamir has really said. Please please read this transacript of his interview. In response to the question "Will Aamir Khan will never join a political party. Will Aamir Khan never contest an election or never start a political party." The reply from Aamir is "No". But still we have right to "feel" his stand political.

Supreme Court was about to give its decision on Narmada Dam. Neither medha Patkar Nor BJP or nobody had requested Aamir to come to India Gate to express his personal views. From his act, I feel that he was interested in publicity for faana or was really childish to act so like guys shown in rang De Basanti.

I agree with him that he has right to express his views and its his fundamental rights. However the platform choosen by him was not correct. He could have express his views to his wife no.1 or wife no.2 or to his frends or Director of rang de basanti..... Even we have our own views for narmada but we dont go to India Gate to express it in front of Media.

He definitely went to India gate to get a cheaper publicity as he is an actor and media would love to cover him. This part hurts everyone. His stand was only for a day and he may not be anymore with Medha patkar and team. He may not join future protests and activities of medha Patkar. Is this a stand ?

Once again, I would like to tell you all that we go by "feel", we "think"... but we dont dont listen and we dont read. In the very 5th question, Rajdeep asks the same thing to him. I have given the link of the transcript. Please read and then let us know again what you "feel".

Where was Aamir when Doctors were protesting reservations ???? Whats his stand on this issue ? 2 days back, on STAR PLUS he said in an interview that we all Indians must understand that political parties are in existance who wish to divide the nation in name of religion and jaati-vaad and etc. As per this philosophy, Congress and Left parties are dividing nation in the name of Jaati-Vaad and reservation issue. however Aamir doesn't want to give comments on reservation.

Aamir has no comments for terrorist attack on Akshardham in Gujarat but he pointed out some incidents where Muslims were sufferors in Gujarat riots.

This is the biggest evidence that my friend has never gone to the fact but only go by the image created to media. Once again I would like you to point to that transcript to make your facts correct. He never ever said on Gujarat riots. Its just and image ppl carry. He categorically deny that he made any such statement and till the time nobody could prove him wrong.

In short, Aamir has no stand. He doesn't wish to accept that he was wrong and his views have hurt people of India. He could have avoid all problems by saying sorry to people who love them. But he prefered not to say sorry to people of India in the name of freedom of speech.

I am still not clear, and I am sure you too are not clear for what purpose he should say sorry. Atleast after reading the transcript of the interview you will not be able to tell for what he should say sorry.

Even Narendra Modi / Govt of India / Gujarat Govt. is in favour of rehabilitation of land owners who would loose their land due to naramda dam. No Indians or Govt have ever stated that dam should be constructed at the cost of any loss to farmers. So in short, Aamir's view are much similar to Narendra Modi. However Narendra Modi doesn't bark like Aamir.

Gujarat Govt., and thus Narendar Modi agreed to what Supreme Court said. And Supreme Court said the same thing what Aamir said. Please decide, who is barking out of these three !

I really feel very bad because Faana is not released in Gujarat. Movie should have been allowed to release in Gujarat. however people of india should have made protest to the movie and prefered not to watch it. I would request all Indians not to see this movie because Aamir has made this stunt just for Faana.

We must not trouble movie makers or coca cola or toyota because Aamir is associated with him. We must not disturb them too. However it is in our hand to use their product or not. We must not watch movies of Aamir or use products for which he is campaigning.

Yes, ofcource, we have right to use the products we like. And going by these logic, please dont drink coca cola, dont take life in toyota and immediately sell you LG phone becuase, LG's latest ad fetures Aamir along with Fana's clip. I am sure the Buy/Sell thread of RimWeb will help you to sell your mobile.

We must tell Aamir Khan that we love actor Aamir Khan and not politician Aamir Khan. And for arrogant Aamir khan, we have no place in our heart. If Aamir is in favour of Narmada Dam, he must issue statement that he is in favour of Narmada dam and had no intention to hurt people of India. He must withdraw his one day stand to Medha and must say sorry to people of India.

Its pitty on those ppl who find Aamir arrogant. I dont have words for them because they dont even care of what Aamir actually said. They just go by the image that media creates for them. Dont know who is arrogant and who is not.

And my friends, it was the message from rang De Basanti " ya to chup baitho ya kuch karo" So someone declared ban on this movie because of Aamir's chilish move...... now why Aamir is crying ? Why he is making stories everyday in paper and tv ? Say sorry and close the chapter...... Or enjoy the fruit of your deeds.

Dont know who is childish. I know one thing that children believe what elders tell them because for them the only authentic source are the elders. But for elders, they have many other things to know what is really the fact.

Edited June 5, 2006 by MOBILE FAN

[MOBILE FAN 42]

It is unfortunate that we are not united.... Aamir has given this message to all Indians that we must believe in Unity and stay away from people who wants to divide. We must accept this view and we must together protest this movie in entire India. Dont stop release of Aamir's movies or dont burn his posters..... simply stay away from his movies and product he promots.

Its unfortunate that even in todays world, in the 21st century ppl go by image and dont want to trouble themselves to find the fact.

If tomorrow some celebrity says that Kashmir must be given to pakistan, will you accpet such arguments in name of freedom of speech ?????? Ya to chup baitho ya kuch karo. Aamir must say sorry....

Sorry Aamir, but thats my views for politician Aamir. Its time to faana....

I am really sorry for those, actually pitty on those who have not undestood the whole point and became pawn of some false political ideology. Except BJP Yuva Morcha - Gujarat, no one has tried to unofficially ban Fana. Not even BJP, there are no statement from the parent party. Even Narendra Modi hasnt said a single sentence on the whole issue. But my friend Dhiren wants all india protests.

Sorry Dhiren, I dont want to become personal to your views but I couldnt stay silent when there are lot many ppl who constantly read RimWeb and build up their view. I must have to follow "Ya chup baitho ya kuchh karo" so I did what I can.

[Dhirens 1]

Dear Mobile Fan,

It seems that you are a great fan of Aamir. In that case, Aamir is very lucky !

I wont go word by word like you. However I must reply. First of all my apologies to you as it clears seems that you are hurt with my views. As mentioned , I have just expressed my views and you have made me a target :-) Was kidding, dont worry. But now you must agree that words or opinions have a capacity to hurt... whether intentional or unintentional. My simple views can hurt someone so deeply who is not at all involved in this issue..... And Aamir, after involving himslef in a complecated and controversial issue still believes that he is right and has not hurt anybody ?

I agree with your views and have a similar view that media makes a story out of nothing. Thanks a lot for giving me a link of transcript. Unfortunately I dont have transcipt of his interview at India gate and Star TV. One has to understand the issue from one's ACT and therefore READ, FEEL etc is not important.

As far as "I FEEL" and etc are concerned, Aamit Khan is not a supreme court of India and his views were full of "I FEEL" only. Please manage to get transcript of his TV interviews for details.

Let me make it very clear once again that,

1. I have similar views like Aamir on Narmada issue. Like Aamir, I agree that the people who are affected because of the dam should be rehabilitated.

2. Gujarat Govt too has this agenda and willing to take care of affected people.

3. Those in favour of dam too believe that affected people should be rehabilitated.

In short, it is a common sense of everybody and nothing great about it.

I also wish to clear you that I am in favour of dam and clearly understand that Aamir too is in favour of dam. So no controversy in this stand.

Therefore let us not discuss if we misunderstood him or media made wrong impressions pf him.

The issue is different. Medha Patkar has a lot of issues for affected people which common people like me and you dont know. This group if fighting with Govt since long. I dont know if they are right or wrong. But they have some issues. People of Gujarat wants water. They dont know who is right and what is right. They want disposal of case at earliest and need water at earliest. What I understand is that the Narmada project will make lacs of people happy at the cost of few thousands and these few thousands shall be compansated for their contribution.

When Supreme Court is working on this issue and matter is very hot, Aamir's sudden stand makes people of Gujarat unhappy. Aamir's sitting with Medha makes them angry because they need water and Aamir is supporting a person who is one of the cause for delay....

You must be very lucky to get 24 hours water in your house. However go to ahmedabad and check the quality of water. I bet you won't drink that salty water. Go on other part of Gujarat and see yourself if water is available. You wont find even salty water there. Many farmers have land but no water. In some part of Gujarat, people buy water from tankers and that their routine. Such infrmation will not be available on Aamir Khan website. For that you should trust me.

So people of Gujarat would have loved Aamir to take same stand from their side...... Aamir could have sit with Gujarat Govt and request affected parties to cooperate so lacs of people can get water. He could have assured affected people that he is with them too.

I have seen his first interview and I am very clear that he is not against dam. I have seen his other TV Interviews too. He indirectly criticised Gujarat Govt for variopus issues too. Is he not targetting Gujarat Govt because Fanna is not released in Gujarat ?

To understand Aamir's act, I dont need transcript. He has many friends but only Rang De Basanti freinds joined him at India gate..... Isn't it filmi ? Is this what you call spontaneous decision ?

So Mobile Fan, You read transcripts and I read acts. Therefore once again I wish to clarify that I have no animity with Aamir. I am also a fan of Aamir but it doesn't mean that I have to appreciate whatever Aamit does. This act was immature and mass people are hurted. Please do not forget that it was aamir's spontaneous decision to join Medha group and at that time he was neither aware of the narmada issue nor had the knowledge of the legal complecations of narmada. He spontaneously issued statements and that became his stand. Therefore I have stated earlier that this act is childish. He was invited by nobody and nobody asked him his views on narmada. So he cannot repeatedly say that he stated same what Supreme Court thinks. In that case he need not have stated anything as Supreme Court already had stated so.

Now the issue is movie and not narmada dam. If he says sorry, he can make everyone happy. Since he is loyal to his ego, he is in no mood to say sorry. And people have made this as an issue. Whether he will say sorry or not is the present issue.

Indians are not targetting Aamir because he is Muslim by birth. He is not a target because he is celebrity. Since his act has hurted a mass public, it is a feeling of Indians that Aamir should say sorry. I dont say that he should say sorry because of his stand.... he should say sorry because we love him and his such act in the name of freedom of speech, religion, target, nation, freedom and etc hurts a lot. This is not expected from Aamir. if you do one thing right, you may not have to do ten wrong things.

Narendra Modi is not in favour of ban on Aamir's film though Aamir has indirectly criticised Narendra Modi. This is a sign on nobelity. Therefore Aamir must learn some lessons from Mr. Modi. Right things happen when you give up "I AM RIGHT". In other countries, cheap stunt results in ban forever and even death fatwa. So liberty should not be taken granted for any act which comes spontaneously.

We are always thankful to actors who come to help mass people for soft issues or tough issues ( aids, tsunami, earthquake) Narmada Dam is a political issue and can not be compared with other issues where stars contribute and help. And what help Medha patkat got with Aamir's stand ? What people of Gujarat got with Aamir's stand ?

Though my appeal will not reach to entire India, and though Fanna had made box office records, I am in favour of self protest against Aamir whether people join or not. Its up to you to do whatever you like. I have expressed my views on the issue.

once again Mobile fan, I am very sorry but I really had no intentions to hurt you....... Kindly accept my apologies.... Afterall I am not Aamir and not going to loose anything in saying sorry. A big sorry to all Aamir fans..... I am in favour of Fanna release in Gujarat and at the same time, my protest continues.

Edited June 6, 2006 by Dhirens

[MOBILE FAN 42]

Its great to hear from you Dhiren. I am happy that you got some understanding. I think ppl with even a little mind will feel good when you say that "I am in favour of dam and clearly understand that Aamir too is in favour of dam."

But I am still failed to know whether you have read the transcript at all or not. This is becuase you once again you say that "He has many friends but only Rang De Basanti freinds joined him at India gate..... Isn't it filmi ? Is this what you call spontaneous decision ?". Why Dhiren why ? Why dont you read the very 5th question to understand that it was sponteneous ? And even after reading the question, if you still think it was filmi then please let me know if you also consider demanding compensation for Bhopal Gas victim, filmi.

I think, you will not read the transcript but I should tell it here for those who are reading this. Aamir went to Delhi for a release of a book. When he was going to the venue he saw two protests happening on the road. One was of NBA and the other were for Bhopal Gas victims. He went to both the places to have first hand information of the issue. He learned and joined both of the group there. Now I want to ask once simple question to all of you who are reading this. What is filmi in this whole episode ? Cant Aamir go Delhi for the release of the book ? Is it filmi if Aamir supports Bhopal Gas victims ? Is it a mistake to ask for rehabilitation for the Dam oustees ?

But friends, everything runs on image... ppl "feel" that Aamir went to Delhi and gave speech from India gate and the whole thing was filmi !

Well Dhiren I agree with you that Medha and party have never done any good to our Gujarat. But they havent done any good to even Maharashtra. I will explain it if you ask how. But currently that is not the point. The point is that we saw Aamir in NBA camp. Yes I felt bad. But the crux is that he did not joined the Medha and the chorus to say that the dam should not be built. He was just asking for rehabilitation and I am happy that you too agree with that. So what is wrong ? Why one should feel sorry ? Is it a shameful act to ask what you, me, Govt. of Guj., Narendra Modi and supreme court is asking ? I appreciate that you consider it as common sense.

I 100% agree with what you described Medha's role in context of Dam. I fully agree that ppl of Gujarat need water. I agree that Sardar Sarovar makes a huge difference to people of Gujarat. Ppl will not only be happy and prosperous but the dam will also improve the economy of whole india. But i dont see anybody including Aamir is disputing it. Infact he understand the fact and he supports the dam. He also wants the dam to be built. So why such hue and cry ?

Mr. Dhiren, No. I am not lucky. We do not have 24 hours water in Pune. And for last one and half year, since when I am in Pune I know that the situation of drinking water is same like what we have in Ahmedabad. Yes, you guessed it right, I am from Ahmedabad and before coming to Pune in mid 2004, I stayed in Ahmedabad from 1984 to 2004. I properly understands the problem what we have in Gujarat. Besides I also have my roots in Saurashtra where water shortage is accute. so for that I dont need to trust anybody as I actually know the ground reality. I am Gujarati by blood and by heart. But What this has to do with Aamir's stand ? Actually it is our stand. We want water and we want to rehabilitate the affected people.

I go by common sense and till the time no one says/express his her views against dam I have no problem. At the same time if somebody does so, he will become anti-hero no.1 for me. Which is not the case with Aamir. For me, anybody who is an obstacle in the growth path of india he becomes hate figure. But I dont think Aamir is any such obstacle.

Dhiren, you even told that Aamir expressed his views on Gujarat or may be Vadodara riots. But there are no such things. From where it came to you ? How can you deny that you go by the image those cheap Gujarati media creates.

Now when you that, he is not anti-dam, anti-gujarat or anti-bjp, for what reason he should say sorry ? Can anybody explain me ? And if it is the thumb rule that anybody who talks about the rehabilitation issue should say sorry then, Narendra Modi should also say sorry, You should also say sorry and I should also say sorry.

His act has not hurted the mass public but the image the Gujarati media has created for him has hurted the mass public. I remember Gujarat Samachar saying "Aamire karela befam nivedano na karane..." (Because of the irresponsible statements Aamir has made...) But the cheap news paper didnt show the guts to put Aamir in double quotes and let the readers decide whether what he said was "befam" or not.

I want to urge all those who wants to protest against Aamir and Fana... please dont drint coca cola. Anyway, it has fertilizers and thus you will save your health if you dont drink it. As you are not allowing Fana to release, also get the Toyota showrooms closed. Never use LG mobiles because Aamir stars in its ad. and if you have alergy with Aamir and thus Fana, you should also have alergy using LG brands. Those who already have LG products should throw away their mobiles, refrigerator, washing machine etc..s from their home and show that they are truly protesting Aamir. Dhiren, my best wishes to you, so that you can persuade the protesters to do this.

[abhay 0]

i never wrote this much even for a 40 mark essay!

bas karo bhai !! TOPIC purana ho gaya & no1 can ever win this debate

[KingofKalyan 0]

LOL........

But it was nice discussion

[BPP 0]

BTW FANAA is running HOUSE full in JamNagar Gujrat ..

Saying that Gujaratis dont want to see FANNA is absolutely rubbish..

http://internationalreporter.com/news/read.php?id=1619

hv fun !

[Ramchi 0]

BTW FANAA is running HOUSE full in JamNagar Gujrat ..

Saying that Gujaratis dont want to see FANNA is absolutely rubbish..

http://internationalreporter.com/news/read.php?id=1619

hv fun !

Da Vince Code might have run FULL house in Chennai if it were allowed but thats not the point.

[adwait 0]

Da Vince Code might have run FULL house in Chennai if it were allowed but thats not the point.

Then what exactly is your point??